Thanks to the internet, and the curse/blessing that is Google Alerts, most authors (if they’re interested) know when a review has been posted of one of their books. I don’t read all my reviews. For my sanity, I can’t, because people tend to either totally love or completely hate my books, and reading a review by someone who hated one of them (which is well within the rights of any reader) tends to derail my concentration and my confidence.
And as writers, in the court of public opinion, we’re not allowed to respond to bad reviews. At all. In any way. It’s considered bad form, and beyond that, there’s no way for the author to come out looking good, even if the review in question is only a “review” in the broadest sense of the word. We come off looking defensive, sensitive, and rude. It’s better just to step away from the internet until the initial frustration over a bad review has a chance to fade.
Authors know this. We remind each other of it regularly.
But I don’t see any reason we can’t respond to/discuss the good reviews, right? ;-)
I found an interesting review of
My Soul To Keep today, and I love it, based purely on the thought that clearly went into it. I’m not going to post the whole thing, because it is rather spoilery, but I am going to show off some snippets, and my thoughts about them.
Here goes (from Lexie’s review of
My Soul To Keep, on Poisoned Rationality):
“It’s not often that you'll find me preferring the third book in a series to
either of the first two, but with My Soul to Keep, third in Vincent's Soul
Screamers novel series, I am. It’s not that I didn't enjoy My Soul to Save and
My Soul to Take, because I loved them both immensely, but I felt like Kaylee had
infinitely more to lose in this book.”
This is true. Everything is on the line for Kaylee in this book, and the stakes are incredibly high, once she understands what’s going on.
“Whether she meant to or not Kaylee had depended upon Nash to be there and
what would happen if he wasn't?”
“For me it felt more real, Kaylee's story that is, because she had to learn
to deal with everything with limited help. She turned to Tod of course, and she
asked for answers in a roundabout way from Harmony (Nash and Tod's mom), but she bears the brunt of things.”
Yes, she does, and I’m proud to say that I think she holds up under the stress nicely. She’s not a physical fighter, like Faythe (from my Shifters series) is, but she’s very strong mentally and emotionally, and she’s very, very smart.
“As she races to save everyone from something, she's also trying to deal
with trust issues, mental issues and guilt.”
Yup. I threw everything I had at her this time, and that wasn’t even my aim in the beginning. But as it turns out, following through on the core issues in this book gave Kaylee a lot to overcome.
“… And Tod does feel bad about it, just he would do it all again if he had
to. He's in the deep gray of morality now that's dead and a Reaper. He isn't as
selfish or calculating as he seems though, several times in MSTK his emotions
get the better of him and he can't help himself. I still love Tod, something so
irrepressible about him that I just can't deny.”
I love Tod, specifically because of his moral ambiguity. And this is one of my favorite aspects of the Soul Screamers series, and one of the parts I work hardest on. The characters are all imperfect, and their flaws span a very broad range. With the exception of Emma, everyone has his or her own goals and motivations, and those are usually in opposition to the goals and motivations of several other characters.
And it’s not that Em doesn’t have a life of her own. It’s just that her interests don’t outright conflict with Kaylee’s. At least, not at this point in the series.
“I had a laugh out loud moment when Sophie gets a small dose of comeuppance
that she desperately needed. She just...I'm not sure how to describe her because
she reaches new levels in this book. Several times I turned to my sister and
asked her 'Is this what girls are really like?' and she would tell me they're
worse in her high school.”
Sophie isn’t based on anyone I knew in school, I swear. I was fortunate enough to have a really good group of friends in high school, three of whom this book is dedicated to. But no one’s completely immune to what goes on in high school.
Sophie is a product of her own environment. And oddly enough, in spite of her material advantages, she’s probably the most disadvantaged character in the book, in terms of ignorance. She doesn’t/can’t understand what’s going on around her, and her frustration manifests as resentment against Kaylee, whom she instinctively knows is at the center of a storm of chaos she doesn’t even fully comprehend. I feel sorry for her.
Kaylee does not. Not anymore, anyway. ;-)
“The book delighted me, in a dark way (I wouldn't say this is a happy book)
and though I was initially quite upset by some of the character developments, I
eventually found myself agreeing with them and understanding why Vincent took
them the route she did.”
Yeah, I’m expecting to get a lot of this. This was not an easy book to write, and it is not an easy book for Kaylee to live through. Things change because of what happens in My Soul To Keep. Consequences are permanent, and after this one, the characters will have to reevaluate their relationships to one another, for better or for worse.
“A lot of what happens in MSTK is a direct consequence of the actions in My
Soul to Save and watching the blame game get tossed around was darkly
amusing.”
Yes! This whole thing started in
My Soul To Save, though readers probably didn’t realize that at the time. I had great fun--and even a few tears--following through on the consequences of one ill-fated moment in the previous book. But I do think the books will stand alone, so don't be scared off by the fact that it's third in the series. ;-)
Now that you've read the discussion, if you want to read the entire review, it's
here. But I warn you: there be spoilers!